YouTube Offline…An Accident or Pakistani Treachery?

February 26th, 2008 by Riley in Internet

YouTube LogoIt was a normal day, the 24th of February, 2008. People were watching Will It Blend? and Leeroy Jenkins on their favourite video site YouTube. That all came to an end at 6:45pm UTC when the Pakistani Government ordered the blocking of the site and managed to take the rest of the world with them.

It all started when the Pakistan Government issued an order to block YouTube because of “offensive content”. The offensive content they were referring to was that of a video of cartoons that made fun of Muhammad from a Danish born cartoonist. Once the order had been isssued, for some unknown reason, a Pakistan Telecom went further and globally broadcast instructions claiming to be the destination for anyone trying to reach YouTube’s various Internet addresses. The flaw was that routers worldwide followed these instructions and directed someone looking for the Numa Numa Guy to an error page. The people who provide the Pakistan Telecom’s Internet connection, Chinese-based PCCW, did not bother to filter the broadcast and allowed it to be sent worldwide.

And just like that, forty-five seconds pass and YouTube is gone for most of the world. People who expected to see funny cats, were left disappointed. YouTube responded fiercely as it fought back trying to overrule the false broadcast with one of their own. Over two long hours, it worked with the number of network providers slowly dropping the false route and returning web-surfers to their beloved site.

All of this may have been an honest mistake, then again, it could’ve been Pakistan getting revenge for the disrespect of their religious figure. We can’t tell exactly what happened but I wouldn’t be surprised if they did plan it. It would be within the operations of the current Pakistani government to do such a thing with riots continuing even after “fair” elections. The Pakistani population, being comprised of mainly Muslims, would find this offensive and be able to justify the blocking of YouTube. In my eyes, I would call it anti-democratic - restricting the freedom speech for all people.

With YouTube back online and serving millions of videos a day to it’s users, the crisis sends a clear message. We need find these flaws and fix the Internet…because I don’t how long I will last not seeing the Crazy German Kid on my screen again.

This entry was posted on Tuesday, February 26th, 2008 at 10:21 pm and is filed under Internet. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

3 Comments to “YouTube Offline…An Accident or Pakistani Treachery?”

  1. Ben Burgess Says:

    Certainly a ridiculous attempt at censoring the world. That wasn’t a flaw per say. The internet is a mesh. A network.

  2. beastman Says:

    someone please hack this stupid telecom

  3. Cyan Aether Says:

    I’m not so sure. If you/your religion was insulted like that, is it that hard to imagine yourself fighting back by shutting down the thing broadcasting the insult? I mean, yeah it was extreme, but I’m not so sure it’s freedom of speech that they were suppressing, but the freedom of slander….

Leave a Reply